| No. | Name | Pos. | Year | B-T | Ht./Wt. | Hometown/Last School |
| 33 | Basil, Michael | Infield | FR | R-R | 6-1/205 | Cincinnati, Ohio/St. Xavier |
| 30 | Carr, Matt | Pitcher | RS JR | R-R | 6-2/185 | Indianapolis, Ind./Bishop Chatard |
| 14 | Collier, Josh | Catcher | FR | R-R | 6-2/190 | Ellettsville, Ind./Edgewood |
| 19 | Cureton, Justin | Outfielder | FR | R-R | 6-2/200 | Indianapolis, Ind./Cathedral |
| 12 | Dickerson, Alex | Outfield | SO | L-L | 6-3/210 | Poway, Calif./Poway |
| 11 | Earley, Michael | Outfield | SR | R-R | 6-0/200 | Anderson, Ind./University of Cincinnati |
| 16 | Ernest, Matt | Pitcher | RS SO | R-R | 6-2/188 | Crown Point, Ind./Crown Point |
| 6 | Heban, Greg | Pitcher | FR | R-L | 6-1/187 | Muncie, Ind./Delta |
| 37 | Herz, Alex | Pitcher | FR | R-R | 6-7/210 | Boulder, Colo./Boulder |
| 15 | Hoffman, Jonny | Pitcher | FR | R-R | 6-0/190 | Oceanside, Calif./El Camino |
| 36 | Igel, Matt | Pitcher | SO | L-L | 6-3/250 | Vincennes, Ind./Rivet |
| 3 | Johnson, Micah | Infield/Outfield | FR | S-R | 5-10/185 | Indianapolis, Ind./Park Tudor |
| 8 | Kleman, Jerry | Infield | FR | R-R | 6-0/175 | Mesa, Ariz./Desert Ridge |
| 39 | Knipp, T.C. | Outfield | JR | S-L | 5-10/175 | Carmel, Ind./Carmel |
| 18 | Knoblauch, Trace | Infield | FR | S-R | 6-4/210 | Houston, Texas/Bellaire |
| 10 | Lambert, Brian | Outfield | RS JR | R-R | 5-9/175 | Pontiac, Ill./Pontiac Township |
| 24 | Leininger, Drew | Pitcher | SO | L-L | 6-1/205 | Poway, Calif./Poway |
| 21 | Lyon, Josh | Catcher | SO | L-R | 6-3/220 | Indianapolis, Ind./Heritage Christian |
| 22 | Mack, Sterling | Outfield | RS JR | L-R | 6-1/185 | Powder Springs, Ga./The Lovett School |
| 40 | McKinley, Mike | Pitcher | FR | R-R | 6-0/175 | Naperville, Ill./Neuqua Valley |
| 17 | Monar, Blake | Pitcher | SO | L-L | 6-1/195 | Rockport, Ind./South Spencer |
| 4 | Ritz, Brian | Infield | SO | L-R | 6-0/195 | Munster, Ind./Munster |
| 1 | Rogers, Tyler | Infield | SR | R-R | 6-0/185 | Lafayette, Ind./Ball State |
| 28 | Roof, Derek | Pitcher | FR | R-R | 6-4/160 | Paducah, Ky./Lone Oak |
| 35 | Sabourin, Jerrud | Infield/Pitcher | JR | L-L | 6-2/215 | San Diego, Calif./Arizona |
| 9 | Serfling, Matt | Outfield | SO | L-R | 5-10/170 | Bloomington, Ind./Bloomington North |
| 20 | Smith, Casey | Pitcher | FR | S-R | 6-1/175 | Bloomington, Ind./North |
| 34 | Squires, Chris | Pitcher | SR | R-R | 6-2/195 | Fort Wayne, Ind./Canterbury |
| 25 | Stadler, Walker | Pitcher | FR | R-R | 6-4/200 | Glenview, Ill./Glenbrook South |
| 31 | Swift, Dylan | Catcher | JR | R-R | 5-10/190 | Princeton, Ind./Princeton |
| 7 | Wilson, Ethan | Infield/Pitcher | RS SO | R-R | 6-0/195 | Pendleton, Ind./Pendleton Heights |
| 5 | Wilson, Wes | Catcher | JR | R-R | 6-0/205 | Lexington, Ky./Mississippi State |
| 29 | Zerman, Alex | Pitcher | RS JR | R-R | 5-9/160 | Highland Park, Ill./Stevenson |
|
